[Tig] "HD vs. film"

Steve Hullfish steve.hullfish
Wed Apr 24 20:51:13 BST 2002

I wrote an article on this subject for the local production magazine in
Chicago. I interviewed several cinematographers that also worked in
video occasionally. They contended that film is actually much easier to
light for than video, because film is more forgiving and its greater
contrast range allows a wider range of acceptable exposures that will
end up delivering a good image. With video, they needed to take much
greater care because they were much more limited with the range of
levels that would yeild an acceptable result. I just interviewed some
image scientists at Kodak recently who had a similar take on the
question. They said that OCN (original camera negative) intentionally
has a huge latitude  so that when printing it or trasnferring it, the DP
or timer or colorist can choose the range that best suits the image.

Rob Lingelbach wrote:
> On Wed, Apr 24, 2002 at 02:13:32PM -0400, john.pytlak at kodak.com wrote:
> > Dear Michel:
> >
> > Here is a link to information about the Cinematographer's Test:
> >
> > http://www.kodak.com/country/US/en/motion/students/filmtech/35hd24p.shtml
> and here's a great paragraph from that page:
> --begin excerpt--
> A question from the audience concerned the impression that video
> is easier or quicker to light. The cinematographers disagreed.
> Schneider replied, "Presently, video makes it easier to make
> images, but it's never been faster or cheaper or better. The
> truth is you can shoot available light with film just as easily
> as you can shoot available light with video. What it really comes
> down to is that quality takes time in any format."
> --end excerpt--
> I hope Kodak and others who recognize the virtues of film
> (discounting for a moment Kodak's vested interest) have their
> lobbying shoes on, to counter what might become political
> pressure to produce content on video only.  Just look at what's
> happened in the PC software industry, where if an educational
> institution wishes to accept Microsoft's donation of hardware and
> software, they must agree not to teach or run any other operating
> system.
> --
> Rob Lingelbach                          http://www.alegria.com
> Sysadm, Computer Animation Lab            rob at film.calarts.edu
> California Institute of the Arts           caltech at calarts.edu
> --
> No marketing or advertising on the tig.  (help wanted ads excepted)
> Send such submissions to tig-announce at tig.alegria.com.
> ...and beware any posts to this mailinglist that appear
>  to promote products without disclaiming financial interest.
> --
> Thank you Ken Robinson for supporting the TIG.
> copyright TIG 2002 all rights reserved.

More information about the Tig mailing list