[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Spirit/C-Reality Comparison at IBC
Reply to: Re: Spirit/C-Reality Comparison at IBC
Dave Corbitt wrote:
>It is my understanding that the so called grain in these images was not
>grain but rather noise.
I asked our Chief Engineer, Joe Bottazzi, to post first hand account of the comparison between the Spirit and C-Reality at IBC. He was the only one from our company that was present at the time. From what he told me right after seeing the comparison, most non-partisan witnesses agreed that the C-Reality seemed cleaner and had a more pleasing look. I think Joe can go into full detail, as well as comment on the issue of whether the Spirit was showing grain detail the C-Reality couldn't resolve or was revealing a visible level of noise in the whites compared to the C-Reality.
On other issues I have to say the ITK Y-front was the most impressive piece of telecine equipment I've seen for a while. In standard def I don't see any advantage a Spirit can have over an Ursa Diamond with Y-Front. I couldn't see any noise in the picture at all, and the scratch concealment is as good as I've seen from a Spirit.
Also, the daVinci 2K looked awesome. I can't wait to get it installed here. IMHO a Y-front equipped Ursa Diamond with a 2K running it is going to be more than a match, in 525/625, for a Mega Def equipped Spirit.
Other than using their equipment I have no affiliation with any company mentioned.
And to JC Soret, it was good meeting you at the show, and I agree, we need more colorists opinions and observations here on the TIG.
Nice Shoes, NY
Thanks to Nigel Hadley & Post Impressions for support in 1998.
No product marketing allowed on the main TIG. Contact rob at alegria.com
1011 subscribers in 39 countries on Thu Sep 24 09:36:24 CDT 1998
subscribe/unsubscribe with that Subject: to telecine-request at alegria.com
complete information on the TIG website http://www.alegria.com/tig3/